Elderly Patients' Preferences for Long-term Life Support
Donald J. Murphy, MD;
Sara Santilli, RN, MSN
Arch Fam Med. 1998;7:484-488.
Objective To study elderly patients' preferences regarding mechanical ventilation and tube feeding and to compare their preferences for short-term use with their preferences for long-term use of these life support interventions.
Design Interviews with patients by clinicians during routine office visits.
Setting Hospital-based, primary care geriatrics clinic in downtown Denver, Colo.
Patients Two hundred eighty-seven elderly persons (mean age, 77 years; range, 60-99 years).
Main Outcome Measures Preferences to use or withhold: (1) short-term mechanical ventilation; (2) long-term mechanical ventilation; (3) short-term tube feeding; and (4) long-term tube feeding.
Results Of the total sample, 253 patients (88%) would prefer short-term mechanical ventilation if the chance of recovering was reasonably good but only 11 (3.5%) would prefer long-term mechanical ventilation. One hundred eighty-nine (65%) would prefer short-term tube feeding, but only 13 (4.5%) would prefer long-term tube feeding in the setting of significant cognitive impairment.
Conclusions Most elderly persons opt for short-term mechanical ventilation or tube feeding if the chance of recovering is reasonably good. Only a small minority would opt for long-term mechanical ventilation or tube feeding.
From Presbyterian–St Luke's Medical Center and GeriMed of America Inc, Denver, Colo (Dr Murphy); and St Joseph's Health Care System, Albuquerque, NM (Ms Santilli).
|
